Go to main contentsGo to search barGo to main menu
Tuesday, November 17, 2026 at 1:47 PM

Rosen Presses Navy on Rancher Compensation

October meeting brings senior officials face-to-face with Fallon families facing permanent grazing losses
Rosen Presses Navy on Rancher Compensation
Senator Jacky Rosen meets with the U.S. Navy, Churchill County, and impacted ranchers at Naval Air Station Fallon. Photo courtesy of Senator Rosen’s office.

U.S. Sen. Jacky Rosen brought senior Navy leadership, Churchill County commissioners and Fallon ranchers together Oct. 30 to address unresolved compensation and road-access disputes stemming from the Fallon Range Training Complex expansion.

For rancher Adrienne Snow, the meeting organized by Rosen’s office provided an opportunity to challenge an assumption she believes has undermined negotiations: that ranching families were given grazing interests by the government rather than purchasing operations whose value depends on them.

“We bought it,” Snow said. “We weren’t gifted anything by the government.”

The meeting included Brendan Rogers, assistant secretary of the Navy for energy, installations and environment, and fifth-generation Nevada ranchers Justin and Adrienne Snow, according to Rosen’s office.

Rosen, a Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, helped secure the modernization compromise in the fiscal year 2023 National Defense Authorization Act. Her office has continued pressing Navy leadership over its implementation through hearings and private meetings.

“It’s extremely important for our national security that the Navy can modernize the Fallon Range Training Complex. From the beginning, my goal has been to ensure that our pilots, SEALs, and Marines are able to receive realistic training while the needs of the local community are met and fair outcomes are achieved for all parties involved,” Rosen said.

“I am glad I was able to bring Navy leadership from Washington, DC, Churchill County, and fifth-generation Nevada ranchers, Justin and Adrienne Snow, together so that Navy leadership could hear directly from impacted stakeholders. We had a productive meeting, and while there is still work ahead of us to justly compensate ranchers for their losses and mitigate the impact on the County, I appreciate the Navy’s willingness to engage with the local community. I will continue working to facilitate a solution that’s fair to Nevada’s ranchers and Churchill County.”

Snow credited Rosen’s team with keeping the ranchers’ concerns before officials capable of resolving them. She also recognized assistance from Nevada Farm Bureau representatives.

The October discussion, she said, exposed gaps in officials’ understanding of how grazing authorizations factor into ranch purchases and the value of an operating livestock business.

Federal grazing permits do not convey ownership of the underlying public land. The Taylor Grazing Act distinguishes grazing privileges from land ownership and separately protects qualifying water rights.

Snow’s argument concerns the investment ranchers made in operations dependent on those authorizations, and what they lose when grazing access disappears.

She said she told Navy leadership that, based on an account relayed to her about an earlier interagency discussion, some officials had continued assuming the government had given ranchers their permits and could take them away without owing substantial compensation.

According to Snow, a Navy participant confirmed that the earlier discussion occurred. Her account has not been independently confirmed with the Navy.

Snow believes those assumptions help explain why offers have fallen short of what ranchers consider the value of their losses. She emphasized that current owners paid for their operations, regardless of how the original grazing authorization came into existence.

Congress addressed compensation in the 2023 defense legislation, which established requirements for roads, replacement forage and grazing losses.

When replacement forage cannot be identified, the law requires full and complete payments for losses resulting from the withdrawal of grazing land for national defense. It requires consideration of the permanent loss of a permit and prohibits limiting payment to its remaining term.

Rosen’s office says greater specificity is needed to fulfill congressional intent and address county impacts. The original compromise also protected more than half a million acres of public land and included environmental safeguards, according to her office.

Rosen questioned Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao about compensation earlier this year, her office said.

A House Appropriations Committee report accompanying fiscal year 2026 defense legislation criticized depreciated loss calculations and called for compensation reflecting generational losses over 100 years when replacement forage is unavailable. The report expresses committee direction, distinct from statutory requirements.

Snow said another important exchange concerned personal financial records. According to her account, Rogers asked about financial information, and Rosen intervened, arguing that public data, an established methodology and congressional direction provided a basis for calculating compensation without additional personal disclosures.

Requirements accepted by her family could become expectations for other ranchers with different operations and recordkeeping, Snow said.

“In a lot of ways, that’s to protect those behind us more than us,” she said.

Snow left encouraged, saying senior Navy officials acknowledged the situation and offered direct follow-up contacts. Compensation remains unresolved, but she said the meeting gave the ranchers an opportunity to explain directly what the permanent loss of purchased grazing access means for their businesses.

 


Share
Rate

Comment

Comments

Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 1
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 2
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 3
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 4
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 1 Page no. 1
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 2 Page no. 2
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 3 Page no. 3
Great Basin Sun - November 13, 2026 - Ford Leads N - page 4 Page no. 4
SUPPORT OUR WORK