Go to main contentsGo to search barGo to main menu
Wednesday, September 16, 2026 at 10:06 PM

What’s Cooking in Kelli’s Dad's Kitchen - Traditions II

Katy Valentine’s Incredible English Plum Pudding
What’s Cooking in Kelli’s Dad's Kitchen - Traditions II
Plum pudding.

In my previous “Traditions post, I shared “Katy Valentine’s Fabulous Fruitcake” recipe, which needed to be started before the end of October to allow the aroma and flavor of the Frey Ranch (https://freyranch.com) whiskey to permeate the fruitcakes. For the same reason, this recipe should be started in early November.

I am a type II diabetic, so I can no longer eat this dessert as it is way too rich for me. If I made this for my friends/family, I would eat more than my share as it is one of my four favorite holiday desserts. I believe that it is also the favorite of several of my siblings, but I am not sure if my daughters like it as I didn’t make it that often. I depended upon a quiet visit to my mom’s home, sneaking in the back door and stealing what I could before being caught.

I will call this one: “Katy Valentine’s Incredible English Plum Pudding”

There are three components to this recipe. The pudding should start early to mid-November, with the Hard Sauce and Vanilla Sauce made on serving day.

If you make this, do not forget to give Kelli and Neil Kelly a dollop of these three items for “taste testing.”  This recipe was made for a family of 10 hungry children, so it should be scaled for a smaller output.

Beforehand, you will need to buy some inexpensive short nylon stockings as the pudding will be stuffed into these for steaming and aging. You will also need a container to seal the final product into for “Step B,” as you did with the fruitcakes. You will also need a source for 2 cups of beef suet or beef tallow, which is the rendered down fat from suet. Amazon and Whole Foods sell tallow in 16 oz quantity.

Ingredients: 
Dried Fruits:
2 cups currents
1 pound raisins (seeded or seedless)
½ pound figs (de-stemmed)
¼ pound citron (candied)
1 cup of your favorite Frey Ranch whiskey.

Step “A”
Mix all of the fruits and whiskey and grind them in a food grinder such as the one shown below. I would grind the fruits two times to ensure they were turned into a mush consistency. Keep your fingers clear as you grind because ground finger is not an ingredient.

Mix together:
2 cups ground suet
2 cups sugar
4 cups bread crumbs
7 eggs
1 cup all-purpose flour
1 tsp cloves
1 tsp cinnamon
2 tsp cream of tartar
The ground fruits

Mix all of the ingredients thoroughly. Let stand overnight. In the morning, add 1 cup of milk and 1 tsp baking soda, again mixing well.
Stuff the pudding into the stockings, tying each off at the top. Then steam for 5 hours, ensuring that the water in the steamer does not fully evaporate.

Step “B” (BOOZE)
When the steaming is complete, and the pudding has cooled, place the stockings in the container onto something that will raise them off the bottom and then pour additional liquor into the bottom, but do not soak the stockings. Seal the container and then set aside in a cool location for at least 3-4 weeks.

The alcohol used before steaming and in the sealed containers will have evaporated and will leave only the aroma and flavor of the liquor of choice.

On the evening that you are going to serve the pudding, make the sauces.

Hard Sauce:
½ cup butter
2 cups powdered sugar
1 tsp vanilla
Mix the ingredients thoroughly.

Vanilla Sauce:
1 cup hot water
1 tbsp cornstarch
½ cup sugar
1/8 tsp nutmeg
1/8 tsp salt
1 tsp vanilla
1 tbsp butter
Mix the ingredients thoroughly.

To serve, place a large dollop of the pudding into a serving dish. Add 1 tablespoon of the hard sauce on top of the pudding, and then pour a small amount of the heated vanilla sauce over the top and serve. Be careful of serving too much, as this should be considered one of the richest desserts made for the holiday season. 

Enjoy, but remember to share with Kelli and Neil Kelly.
- Kelli Kelly's Dad, Earl Valentine, and author of “Identity – Dream Maker.



Share
Rate

Comment

Comments

COMMENTS
Comment author: Jeff goings Comment text: September 11, article Civics 101 I would like to commend Rachael Dahl and the Fallon post for their article. Civics 101. This is a reminder that we as citizens live in a representative form of government and why it is so important that we vote as voting is our way of making our voice heard. Comment publication date: 9/11/26, 1:30 PM Comment source: Churchill County Board of Commissioners Updates Comment author: PRF Comment text: Knew Sis from the B of A as a teller and in social gatherings around Fallon. When we bought our land in Kingston, Sis regaled us with her stories of gatherings at the old restaurant & bar on the way to Groves lake. Sis often said, 'What happens in Kingston stays in Kingston!' Fun & funny lady. Comment publication date: 9/8/26, 5:58 PM Comment source: Marilyn J. “Sis” Banovich Comment author: Ruth Fiege Comment text: So sorry for the pain your family is suffering. She is in comfort of Jesus arms. This is Ruth Fiege, Gary's cousin from WI. I can't begin to imagine the pain your family is suffering. So much comfort in knowing she and baby are with Jesus. God Bless you all during this tragedy. Love, Ruth Fiege Comment publication date: 9/8/26, 11:35 AM Comment source: Obituary: Charissa Mae Lunderstadt Comment author: Eric Comment text: FOIL the records/images for County vehicles, for safety..... Comment publication date: 9/4/26, 8:25 AM Comment source: Amid Flock Camera Concerns, CCSO Explains Its License Plate Readers
SUPPORT OUR WORK